The True Kings of Current Gen: Your Results

[Wools]

A decade?

Maybe not.

[wakka]

Pretty good list. I think Galaxy 2 is a better game than 1 though.

[shaffy_oppa]

I've played (not completed) everything on that list except Galaxy, Skyward Sword and Sin and Punishment 2... Only played Zelda: TP for the hack so does that count? Oh and haven't gotten around to ME2 yet... I've probably started and gotten to the endgame in the first ME around 6 or 7 times.

[MonkeyJuggleDX]

Nice to see Vanquish so high up the list.

[rmoxon]

Do I win a prize for having not played any of the top ten?

You need to play Uncharted 2 right now before you make another post on this forum.

[S3M]

05 - Mass Effect

Corrected your typo for you

Seriously I'm guessing alot of people here didn't play the first ME and the 2 & 3 games are rubbish when compared to the first as there buggy and very dumbed down.

Bit of a rubbish top 10 sadly, I mean The Last of Us? that's just a now playing list

No

Dark Souls
Ni no Kuni
Valkyria Chronicles
Dead Rising
Armored Core For Answer
Majin and the Forsaken Kingdom
Resonance of Fate
Heavy Rain
Blue Dragon
Eternal Sonta
Fallout 3
Elder scrolls IV or V?

Nier's good but it's not a top 10 RPG game and the lack of PSN or XBLA games is criminal.

[speedlolita]

You clearly stated that you have played only a few hours of Nier. How can you condemn it to not being a top 10 RPG without even having experienced all it has to offer?

[S3M]

Because it isn't Valkyria Chronicles and Dark Soul are hands down the best RPG's this gen I played.

speedlolita I doubt you've played/owned even half this gen's RPG compared to me. Nier is quite heavily talked about compared to some of the other RPG's it good but it's not the best. It's has now got quite a cult following and deserved it's status as one of the more better games this gen, but it's not the best.

Magnacarta II & Trinity: Souls of Zill O'll are two examples, of two real unsung RPG gems this gen.

[prinnysquad]

That didn't answer the question whatsoever.

[charlesr]

The internet isn't about answering questions. It's about being the best.

Obviously the reason that the list does not contain Deadly Premonition is that everyone just assumed it rather than bother to actually write it down.

[Neil]

Interesting top 10, I have played just one (MGS4) and didn't even manage to finish that...

I did buy quite a few more but erm didn't get around to playing any of them, I have played 4 of the second 10 though

[Guts]

Corrected your typo for you

Seriously I'm guessing alot of people here didn't play the first ME and the 2 & 3 games are rubbish when compared to the first as there buggy and very dumbed down.

Bit of a rubbish top 10 sadly, I mean The Last of Us? that's just a now playing list

No

Dark Souls
Ni no Kuni
Valkyria Chronicles
Dead Rising
Armored Core For Answer
Majin and the Forsaken Kingdom
Resonance of Fate
Heavy Rain
Blue Dragon
Eternal Sonta
Fallout 3
Elder scrolls IV or V?

Nier's good but it's not a top 10 RPG game and the lack of PSN or XBLA games is criminal.

The list voted by multiple people isn't exactly the same as my personal list! Oh the outrage!

Mass Effect 2 is better than ME1 in every way. Graphics, more streamlined gameplay (that does away with the rubbish like Mako and the cluster f*** inventory), characters, combat, you name it.

Also Fallout 3 is sh*t compared to New Vegas btw. and a rubbish RPG.

[S3M]

That didn't answer the question whatsoever.

Because it not as good as Valkyria Chronicles I don't have time to play ever game as much as I like, after 10 hous of Nier and 10 hours of Valkyria Chronicles I choose to finish Valkyria Chronicles over Nier. Some dau I'll get back to it so right back at you.

Now to answer my question prinnysquad and speedlolita have you played the following RPG's to compare with Nier?

Dark Souls
Ni no Kuni: White Witch
Valkyria Chronicles
Resonance of Fate
Blue Dragon
Eternal Sonta
Lost Odyssey
Infinite Undiscovery
3D Dot game heroes
Magnacarta II
Trinity: Souls of Zill O'll

Let me know when you have as these are all the best ones these gen I'd say

[fuse]

Well, I certainly don't agree with you on Ni no Kuni.

[prinnysquad]

Yes, no, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, no, no, no.

All yes games were inferior in terms of how much I enjoyed them.

Now that's how you answer a question. I love the image of you playing Nier and Valkyria concurrently, up to ten hours apiece, then choosing which hoss to throw your lot in with.