Finished this yesterday. No spoilers but I like the way the story played out. I've been a mostly good cowboy but I think I'll wreak a bit of havoc and then sell it.

It's a very impressive game, I enjoyed it, but there's a lot of listening to dialogue whilst trotting around on horses and I didn't really feel compelled to go and do much exploring. I can't help but compare it to BOTW and find it inferior, as with every open world game since.