Critics Club III: Film of the Year 2005

[Neon Ignition]

Time to take the big hitters from the previous three rounds to determine once and for all what truly is...

Film of the Year 2005



Which of the above movies really is the greatest of the year?

[teddymeow]

Damn!! This is a tough choice.

Batman Begins is the easiest to watch so would get more repeat viewings.

Kiss Kiss Bang Bang is absolutely brilliant. So sharp and a great turn by both RDJ and Val Kilmer.

Serenity is just pure fan service. It was nice to see Joss Whedon get a chance to say some sort of goodbye to Firefly.

The Machinst is exceptional. Not easy to watch but compelling and stays long in the memory.

Hmm, Serenity it is.

[CMcK]

I can’t choose between Serenity and The Machinist so they’re both the best.

[Neon Ignition]

Begins and Serenity though there are a couple on there I'm still yet to see. Begins is the last good Batman movie whilst Serenity... I faltered but then figured if this had been tweaked into a Star Wars movie people would still be crushing to it on mass.

[CMcK]

If only Star Wars movies were as good as Serenity.