Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Beatles: Rock Band [PS3/360]

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    The Beatles: Rock Band [PS3/360]

    My copy arrived today and I pretty much hammered the Story mode to completion in one session.

    First impressions were favourable: the excellent intro movie that's been doing the rounds on the internet for a month or so now kicks off the game in a stunning manner, setting the mood nicely. You then get prompted to calibrate the audio/visual offset (and bizarrely win a trophy in the process) before getting dumped in the Main Menu.

    As has been documented elsewhere, all songs (except for the bonus final song) are available from the off in Quick Play, although I'd honestly recommend avoiding this mode and going straight for Story Mode. I know a couple of others have suggested going straight for a particular song:

    Sgt. Peppers/Little Help

    .

    But really: don't.

    When taken away from the context of the rest of it, it really loses a lot of its impact.

    So, Story Mode...

    Well it basically starts off as a setlist in various venues, bookended by some highly swish video sequences setting the tone of the era wonderfully. And, if I'm brutally honest, during the first part of Story Mode it really does feel like a by-the-numbers approach to a band-focused Rock Band game. There's nothing you've not seen before once the game is in progress - you get the Beatles performing on stage with a few inserted crowd reaction shots. It's the Rock Band you know and love.

    Between songs it's a little different - you unlock photos depending on your performance, and after a certain number of photos have been unlocked, you earn video prizes. Once you've completed an entire setlist for each venue, you then unlock a Challenge mode for that particular venue (which is basically playing the entire setlist back-to-back, earning you another photo if you complete the challenge with maximum stars).

    As I was playing through the early stages, to be honest I was a little disappointed. Sure, I was really enjoying it and grinning throughout but, y'know, it was Rock Band. But then something happens:

    You reach Abbey Road. And the whole thing takes off like some ginormous phoenix of ruddy awesomeness.

    The whole game is transformed. It ceases to become a rhythm action game and it turns into an unbelievably stunning interactive experience. I don't care how poncey I sound saying that - it's true.

    Every song becomes something special - something that you feel truly, inherently connected with. You forget that what you're doing is sitting in front of a screen playing on a plastic instrument - you get completely sucked into the utterly beatiful events going on in the background, your eyes wanting to look away from the scrolling notechart, desperate to give in to the kaleidoscopic carcophany begging to be watched above.

    It's no exaggeration to say that it's one of the most artistically brilliant videogames yet released. It's gorgeous. I want to give examples, but I don't want to ruin anyone else's first experiences.

    The loading screens also add to the atmosphere, featuring never heard before banter between recordings, as well as the odd comment on completion of a song. You get counted into the songs by the chaps too, rather than having the typical Rock Band high-hat count-in. All of this sounds very minor and periphery, but in terms of keeping you fully immersed into the experience, it's all brilliant stuff.

    And so the ginormous phoenix of ruddy awesomeness stays soaring until the conclusion and you end up feeling satisfied. Feeling like you were on a journey rather than just playing a sequence of songs.

    And this is why I recommend playing the Story Mode rather than dipping into Quick Play. When dipping into the songs willy-nilly, I can really see this just feeling like a by-the-numbers Rock Band game and people wondering what the fuss was all about. But when played as a single, long experience, it becomes something else entirely.

    I can honestly see myself playing through the Story from the beginning again on more than one occasion, treating it almost like a movie - using it as a way to escape for 2-3 hours, immersing myself in that experience once more.

    I felt truly connected to the Beatles and to their music when playing this game - something that just hasn't happened with any other band in any other music game. It didn't happen with Guitar Hero: Metallica, it didn't happen with any band-specific Rock Band DLC such as AC/DC, Maiden, Pearl Jam, etc. But it happened with this.

    Which, in my book, makes it an utterly fab success.

    I can only hope it helps a new generation of people appreciate the genius of the Beatles, introduces a whole new generation or people to one of my favourite pastimes and encourages Harmonix to make many, many more games with such passion and love.

    #2
    I would quote the whole post above for truth but that would be a bit silly.

    Can't agree more!!

    My wife and I have done the first few chapters this evening (would have done more but got home from work late) and it just oozes class.

    From a technical point of view the Hofner guitar is class. No more clicky buttons (thank God) and the drums are nowhere near as annoying as they used to be. They give off a less clacky noise than the RB1 drums. Am I right in asuming the drums with this are the RB2 drums that Europe never got? There are extra connections underneath them which I guess are for cymbals.

    Another cool thing for the PS3 drums is that they are now wireless.

    So yeah, buy it! It's phenomenal. And the Ltd Edition actually seems to be Ltd which makes a nice change.

    Can't wait until tomorrow to pick up my Rickenbacker!!

    Comment


      #3
      This game is absolutely beautiful. One of my favourite games + my favourit bad = If anybody can grab a code for the preorder songs I'd really appreciate it

      Comment


        #4
        I too played through the entire career mode in one sitting and was completely absorbed.

        As was said above, as soon as you get to Abbey Road the amazing visual trips start. For me at least this is the point when the music gets better too.

        My only gripe is when you play other instruments instead of the guitar, but tbh i love the songs so much i totally forgive it. (unlike gh5's Superstition by Stevie Wonder!)

        Drum fills have also been ditched for this game which is great. Now the green crash note just comes up during normal play after you have accumulated enough "beatlemania".

        I'm already a big Rock Band fan and this game lives up to and exceeds expectations in my opinion. Love it.

        Comment


          #5
          I'm soooooo looking forward to t his. My Nikyo guitar arrived this morning and Amazon US shipped my game yesterday on the 8th. So with luck I'll be jamming away by the weekend. I just can't wait! My first guitar based game too so what a way to kick it all off.

          yakumo

          Comment


            #6
            Btw, none of us were suggesting going straight to Sargeant Peppers, only that the moment you hit that song in career, the game goes into the stratosphere.

            Thats what I was saying anyway, no way you should skip straight to it!

            Comment


              #7
              Haven't got this yet as I came home early to look after a poorly better half but the drums described above in the pack are indeed the standard wireless RB2 versions and are much more superior to the old RB originals.

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by Jebus View Post
                Btw, none of us were suggesting going straight to Sargeant Peppers, only that the moment you hit that song in career, the game goes into the stratosphere.

                Thats what I was saying anyway, no way you should skip straight to it!
                You are correct, double-checking the thread, you never said to skip straight to it. Someone else did, though - post #202. And I guess that stuck in my memory. So just in case it stuck in someone else's memory too - anyone else's memory - I'd like to urge them not to skip straight to it.

                Reading through my first comment above again, I notice I didn't touch on anything technical - stuff like sound quality, notechart quality, Trophies/Achievements, other features...

                At the time, stuff like that didn't seem to matter.

                Still, for people who are interested in that kind of thing, the sounds quality is brilliant; obviously it's the remastered tracks being used and they sound glorious. I guess it's testament to their quality that I was able to get so fully absorbed in the experience.

                Notecharts for guitar at least - I'm yet to try the bass or drums - seem fine. There are times when you get to play

                sitar and piano

                but, other than that, no surprises. Harmonix haven't added artificial difficulty for the sake of it - your hands perform approximations of every note intuitively and naturally.

                Trophies have been done in a similar way to, say, Valve's achievement structure, where a lot of them have bars that gradually fill up as you go through their criteria. Once the bar is complete you get that Trophy. There are also song-specific challenges, such as playing 100% of hammer-ons and pull-offs in certain songs, getting 100% in the drum solo on
                on Expert difficulty, that kind of thing. It will definitely be a challenge to get all of them.

                The options menu allows features such as Hyper Speed Mode (increases the notechart scroll speed) and Performance Mode (removes the notechart entirely) from the off without cheat entry, as well as a Realistic Mode which made me smile - this cranks up the crowd volume to deafening levels apparently, although I'm yet to try it.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Played some last night, i think its fantastic , you can see harmonix have put so much effort into this, i didnt want to do to much as my new guitar is coming today so will play more later, one thing i dont like is how the songs are open in quickplay from the start, i think as you progress the story they should become available, but hey i dont have to play them, but its tempting to play your favourites straight away. very happy with the way the game has turned out though.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Great first impressions.
                    Going into town to get this for a family session this weekend, would the general consensus be to upgrade my RB1 BIAB instruments? Or just the guitar? Finally are the new drums wireless?

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Originally posted by neil2k View Post
                      Great first impressions.
                      Going into town to get this for a family session this weekend, would the general consensus be to upgrade my RB1 BIAB instruments? Or just the guitar? Finally are the new drums wireless?
                      I folded and bought the new instruments and am so glad that I did. The drums are wireless and far less 'clacky' than the RB1 drums and the fret buttons on the guitar are quieter too.

                      If you can afford to get the new tech I would, just don't expect a great trade-in offer on your old stuff. HMV apparently were giving silly money (in a good way) for the old kit but whether that is still valid today I don't know.

                      Now, go and get Beatling!!

                      Comment


                        #12
                        I thought is was just me, but the drums do sound a lot quieter than the original ones. Better quality pads perhaps?

                        The only thing that's disappointed me about this game so far is that when you fail a song you don't turn into The Monkees.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Sold! Didn't take much persuading did I
                          I'll go into hmv and see what the deal is, if it's crap I'll probably keep them as spares. Still got my ghero2 and GheroWT guitars as well, so I need to justify the new kits general greatness to the wife!

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Originally posted by teddymeow View Post
                            If you can afford to get the new tech I would, just don't expect a great trade-in offer on your old stuff. HMV apparently were giving silly money (in a good way) for the old kit but whether that is still valid today I don't know.
                            Do you have any idea how much they were/are offering?

                            Comment


                              #15
                              the instruments comments are intersting, as IGN reckon they are no better than the previous hardware, but of course they could be talking about the rockband 2 instruments that i dont think we ever got here, they better be good as ?90 just for a guitar is a bit crazy if there not much better.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X