Edge 209...

[toythatkills]

From GAF, pinch of salt for now

Modern Warfare 2: 9
Assassin's Creed 2: 8
Left 4 Dead 2: 9
Bayonetta: 10
Legend of Zelda: Spirit Tracks: 8
Sin and Punishment: 8
Dragon Age:Origins: 5 (360 version tested if that counts for something?)
Saw: 4
Lit: 7
Resident Evil: The Darkside Chronicles 7
Football Manager 2010: 8
Tropico 3: 7
Spaceball Revolution: 5

[fishbowlhead]

You sure about that 10 for bayonetta??

[toythatkills]

Nope, I haven't got Edge yet, but GAF is!

[spagmasterswift]

YAY! Edge gets something right at last!!!

[prinnysquad]

Bayonetta 10? Oh Noes! Team Andromeda is going to be on the warpath!

Dragon Age 5? ... engage lemon sucking expression. ):0

[Geoff D]

I'm cancelling my subscription to this thread.

[C']

If that Bayonetta score is correct I'm STARTING a subscription to Edge.

It's almost unbelieavble. Not that I don't think it could possibly worth a 10 as almost everyone who speaks about it is overwhelmingly positive but I never imagined it could an Edge 10.

Once again I regret that my 360 is a PAL unit and there's no way I'm going anywhere near the PS3 version.

[toythatkills]

10 confirmed, just got Edge

[prinnysquad]

I've seen so many decent reviews for Tropico 3, and apparently it's quite cheap, so I may have to get it. Loved the first one, especially the soundtrack.

[Geoff D]

10 confirmed, just got Edge

Is it the 360 version? Or both?

[egparadigm]

That 10 is a massive surprise. I'm pretty sure EDGE had some major reservations in the last preview I read. Maybe it came on leaps and bounds?

[prinnysquad]

That was just a sleight of hand before the big TA-DA!

[toythatkills]

Is it the 360 version? Or both?

360 version was tested

[abigsmurf]

Bayonetta has always looked stunning. I think a lot of the reaction to the universally glowing reviews it's getting can be summed up as "wtf? but this game has boobies! No game with boobies should get full marks!".

Dragon Age is surprising but I couldn't imagine playing it without the active pause system which possibly goes part way to explaining it. There's no doubt the game is heavily flawed (mostly in terms of balance) but I enjoyed it start to finish.

[toythatkills]

I haven't played Dragon Age but I gave it a 3 in my mind for being made by BioWare.

So it's outperformed expectations!