This might be a little ps3 biased but hey, let me check your scores against mine

[Neon Ignition]

They suck because they don't spend enough time on it, they don't spend enough time on it because it sucks

[Number45]

I've only had one truly frustrating experience with MS. That was on one of the later races on MS2, and only because I refuse to continue without the gold. I find the races so involving that I'm willing to race over and over in order to perfect the route and grab that gold - same as I did for MNR despite people calling out it's insane difficulty.

It's weird, because aside from those I much prefer time based racers as opposed to having competitors on the track.

[ExtremePabs]

Late to the party but heres mine

Resistance 2 - 6
Uncharted - 8
Uncharted 2 - 9
Metal Gear Solid 4 - 5
Motorstorm - 2 (the 2 is purely for the graphics which were pretty good the game was awful)
Borderlands -9 (for me one of the best coop games ever)
SF4 - 7
Super Mario Galaxy - 4
Super Mario World - 4
Virtua Fighter 5 - 7

add a couple of my own

Chromehounds - 8 (would have been a ten if there was any for of Single Player)
Demon Souls - 9
Mass Effect 2 - 9
forza 3 - 7
Modnation - 9
LBP - 4
Rainbow Six Vegas 2 - 9
GOW 1 + 2 - 7
Halo 3 - 9
halo odst - 7

As you can probably guess I dislike platformers

[Neon Ignition]

I think I just find Motorstorm frustrating. The collision detection is awful with a stray twig capable of stopping the car dead and the difficulty level is badly judged. It's frustrating as each MS has appealed more than the previous but they get undermined by the obvious errors. They've mentioned rebalancing MS:A but I'm not holding out too much hope, already seen a pebble stop the car in a vid

They need to embrace the arcade leanings the series has more. It's a series that's on the cusp of being great.

[NemesiS]

Resistance 2 - 5.5
Uncharted - 7.5
Uncharted 2 - 9
Metal Gear Solid 4 - 8.5
Motorstorm 6
Borderlands 8.7 (in co-op at least)
SF4 (not played super), 6.5
Super Mario Galaxy - 7
Super Mario World - 9.5
Virtua Fighter 5 - 6

Mine:

Resistance 2 - 5 - Very boring tbh

Uncharted - 8 - Great game and still standout even now

Uncharted 2 - 9 - Close to a 10. Improved on the original in every way

Metal Gear Solid 4 - 6 - Boring interactive movie really

Motorstorm - 6 Good for the first two hours or so then becomes repetetive

Borderlands (in co-op at least) - 7 - Found this monotonous after 2.5 years of WoW

SF4 (not played super), - Not played since being bored senseless of SF on PS1

Super Mario Galaxy - 10 Perfect 3D Mario

Super Mario World - 10 - Perfect 2D mario

Virtua Fighter - 6 - Not played as hate fighters full stop these days

[kernow]

I didn't actually mind motorstorm but I don't think I've raged so much in quite a while, the AI was infuriating. Make one mistake and 6 cars whizz past you in a perfect racing line. It looked nice enough. I think I got to like, level 4 or something and I was racing some really slow trucks and thought .. why the hell am I bothering to play this, after about 3 times trying the same race.

Also I am never a fan of holding the trigger to accelerate, it just feels wrong, I set it to the X/O button and didn't win many races while doing so, on the offcuff I set it back to the triggers and was winning the same races, thus the face controls were .. broken basically, might have been patched later on but you simply couldn't go as fast using them.

I never bothered with the 2nd as the first almost made me snap a pad holding it too tight. Now I just stare at the ps3 while it sits in standby, I find it more fun than trying to play something on it.

[Super Monkey Balls]

Resistance 2 - 7
Uncharted - 7
Uncharted 2 - 9
Metal Gear Solid 4 - 9
Motorstorm 8.5
Borderlands Never played it
SF4 9
Super Mario Galaxy - 8
Super Mario World - 9
Virtua Fighter 5 - 8
Xbox 360 - 10

[kernow]

Resistance 2 - 7

Xbox 360 - 10

[Super Monkey Balls]

Some perfect 10's btw:

Zelda OOT
Sonic 2
Super Monkey Ball
Sega Rally
Panzer Dragoon Orta
Super Mario 64
Gradius V

[msm13579]

nice to see some dislike for motorstorm, most people i know seem to think its great, but the handling is so basic it makes the game boring imo.

[Number45]

Also I am never a fan of holding the trigger to accelerate, it just feels wrong, I set it to the X/O button and didn't win many races while doing so, on the offcuff I set it back to the triggers and was winning the same races, thus the face controls were .. broken basically, might have been patched later on but you simply couldn't go as fast using them.

The face buttons are analogue, and I'm sure switching the controls to those buttons will retain the analogue control so you'd need to be pressing the buttons HARD (I tested this last night, although not on MS) to make sure you were getting 100% throttle.

[kernow]

Yeah, I'm pretty sure I was, its long been sold anyway. 5 games in my ps3 stack and two aren't even mine. Badical.