Official Edge 151 thread - scores inside

[John Beaulieu]

Psychonauts 8/10
Destroy All Humans 6/10
Cold Winter 6/10
Nintendogs 7/10
Stella Deus:The Gate Of Eternity 6/10
Dead To Rights 2 3/10
Area 51 6/10
Boiling Point 2/10
Star Wars :Revenge Of The Sith 4/10
Dynasty Warriors 5/10
Smart Bomb 3/10

------------------------------------------------------------

[martTM]

Lots of ouch there... not sure if it's all deserved though.

[John Beaulieu]

I am guessing from your post that you have reviewed some of the above games in a different light? (this could be the obscure reference you made in a recent thread)

[baad bwoy]

Nintendogs only getting 7, is this a fair score?

[John Beaulieu]

btw **** knows how Smart Bomb got 3/10 ... ****ing atrocious game that I am struggling to find a single iota of enjoyment within .... and i was sooo looking forward to it

[John Beaulieu]

Nintendogs only getting 7, is this a fair score?

Depends if you own a real dog or not

[Fuddle]

Nintendogs only getting 7, is this a fair score?

yes.
dont know what they say, but you can see its fairly limited after a while.

[baad bwoy]

Depends if you own a real dog or not

I own a real dog, does this mean it isn't worth getting, and I wonder what real dogs think of the game, anyone tried introducing their nintendog to their real dog

[Kotatsu Neko]

Such a shame that Psychonauts, one of the most original and entertaining games this gen only got an 8. I'd be tempted to give it a 10 personally, or at least a 9. It's truly superb.

Amusing too they give Nintendogs 7, when Famitsu gave it a perfect 40/40. Edge as usual, can't reist throwing up those 'WTF?' scores. Bit sad really.

[John Beaulieu]

Amusing too they give Nintendogs 7, when Famitsu gave it a perfect 40/40. Edge as usual, can't reist throwing up those 'WTF?' scores. Bit sad really.

I have more faith in any Edge review than the fanzine known as Famitsu's 'grab a guy off the street and let him give 4-5 lines about a game and then throw any score at it'.

[martTM]

btw **** knows how Smart Bomb got 3/10 ... ****ing atrocious game that I am struggling to find a single iota of enjoyment within .... and i was sooo looking forward to it

Really? I actually quite like it. It's certainly not perfect, but I've enjoyed the time I've spent with it. Surprisingly though, my PSP's been sitting dormant for a few weeks - just not felt like picking it up. Almost like *gasp* it's the games that make it and there's just nothing on there that keeps me interested.

And there I was thinking that the fact that it was shiny and expensive was the biggest selling point.

[butchcvc]

I have more faith in any Edge review than the fanzine known as Famitsu's 'grab a guy off the street and let him give 4-5 lines about a game and then throw any score at it'.

i'd rather listen to a guy of the streets opinion about a game than the pretentious dribble thats written in edge!

[Kubrick]

Dynasty Warriors 5/10

The PSP game?

[Ady]

Such a shame that Psychonauts, one of the most original and entertaining games this gen only got an 8. I'd be tempted to give it a 10 personally, or at least a 9. It's truly superb.

Amusing too they give Nintendogs 7, when Famitsu gave it a perfect 40/40. Edge as usual, can't reist throwing up those 'WTF?' scores. Bit sad really.

7 is a good score though.

And Famitsu dish out ridiculously high scores like they were going out of style.

Anyway, articles??

[Poots]

Time Extend, Making of, etc?