DMC3:SE or DMC4?

[Kongster]

The Tin version is not worth for the extra fiver or so in my opinion.

[saturn-gamer]

DMC3 SE is better overall, but DMC4 on both the standard difficulties is less annoying for a casual player.

Its just that Capcom lacked the balls to get rid of Dante for DMC4. Its Nero's game, as being said before. And the DMC4 mechanics are also tailored towards him. Its sad that we can't use him full time.

As some kind of seasoned DMC player (finished DMC1, and US DMC3 which is by far the hardest DMC) I found DMC4's Devil Hunter to be slightly too easy. Son of Sparda was really fun. Currently I'm about 5 missions in Dante Must Die, and its here where DMC4 raised to A+ material for me. DMC4's DMD is not cheap as the previous ones.

[Mad Gear]

The US DMC4 Spesh Ed comes with an extra disc which has episodes of the DMC anime + some other stuff iirc.