Edge 207

[Lebowski]

Quite surprised to not see anything up for this already. Postal strike must be hampering the regular posters.

Ton of reviews this month awful cover nothing of interest in the features really, war devil, Joe Danger, new Castlevania, Assassin Creed 2, Jeff Minter


scores a s follows

Halo 3 odst, 9
Dead Space extraction, 8
Scribblenauts, 7
Demon's souls, 9
section 8, 7
Mini Ninjas, 7
katamari forever, 7
Need for Speed Shift, 8
wet, 5
Fifa 10, 9
Ninja Gaiden Sigma 2, 7
Motorstorm Artic edge, 7
Gran Turismo psp, 7
Guitar Hero 5, 7
Beatles rock band, 7
Zumas revenge, 8
Professor Layton and Pandora's box, 7
Blood bowl, 3
Metroid prime trilogy, 8

[Skull Commander]

*Awaits angry Beatles brigade*

[PeteJ]

*Awaits angry Beatles brigade*

Score seems spot-on to me!

[Malc]

Shift an 8? What are they basing that on, the potential of the game or what the game is like now?

[Jebus]

There's quite a few scores I disagree vehemently with there. Beatles, GH5, Wet, ODST and Metroid Trilogy specifically.

[Largo]

odst 9 lol wtf

[Malc]

They seem to be too generous this month.

[Atticus]

I don't even own Beatles Rockband but find it amazing they moan about no Eleanor Rigby ... a song that features no drums or guitars I can only assume their version comes with the cello & violin expansion pack.

[Dogg Thang]

That's a lot of 7s.

Anyone know what they said about Layton?

[Eight Rooks]

Nah, Wet I can't agree with. Even being as cynical as I know how I would still give it a 6 minimum. Too much fun, very obvious flaws aside. Demon's Souls is spot on, though... not quite a ten, but a fantastic, fantastic game.

[Family Fry]

5 for wet, it's not THAT bad.
They should have lobbed it a 7 match the other scores, I SO would cancel my subscription etc.

[Jebus]

WET is a 5...if you are a pretentious prick who's forgotten why they even loved videogames in the first place.

To everyone else it's a high 6, low 7.

[teddymeow]

A 9 for FIFA. Wonder what they'll give PES?

[Matt]

I don't even own Beatles Rockband but find it amazing they moan about no Eleanor Rigby ... a song that features no drums or guitars I can only assume their version comes with the cello & violin expansion pack.

Think you're giving Edge far too much credit there mate, they don't review, they court controversy. They write a review to get people yacking (more online yacking = more sales, right!) and then run it once through a thesaurus

[NW2013]

odst 9 lol wtf

Yeah, it's getting a panning in a lot of places as little more than an expansion pack yet gets nearly full marks here. Bizarre.