Game of the Year 2007 - Closing soon - please post

[huxley]

GOTY SMG

Honorable Mention Bioshock / Halo 3

[Ratso]

Super Mario Galaxy

just (and I mean just) pipping Guitar Hero II on the 360, and a second honourable mention to The Orangey Box of Delights

['Press Start']

Super Mario Galaxy

Honorable mention goes to Halo 3 (Live), Mass Effect and Assasins Creed for me.

[NeoStuey]

Game of the year

Assassin's Creed

Honourable mentions

Call Of Duty 4

Uncharted: Drake's d

Bladestorm: The Hundred Years' War

[Goldenballs]

GOTY - CoD4

Honourable mentions:

Bioshock
The Darkness
Crackdown

[Onii]

Halo 3

Honourable mentions -
Cod4
Bioshock

[Gradius]

GOTY - Super Mario Galaxy

Honourable Mentions -

Skate
Crackdown
Orange Box

[cutmymilk]

GOTY - Mario Galaxy

Honourable mentions:
Orange Box
Halo 3
Zelda: Phantom Hourglass

[kingmobster]

GOTY:
Super Mario Galaxy

Honorable mentions:
The Orange Box
Tomb Raider Anniversary
Rock Band

[mr_sockochris]

GOTY - Super Mario Galaxy

Honorable mentions - Orange Box, CoD4, Crackdown

[Kevvy Metal]

GOTY

Super Mario Galaxy!



Honourable mentions

Orange Box.
Halo 3
Call of Duty 4
Sega Rally
Space Giraffe
Bioshock (It's not crap)
Crackdown
EDF!! 2017
....and on and on...

2007 rocked!!

Most Disappointing GOTY

Assassin's Creed.

proper rubbish

[FreelancePolice]

GOTY

Super Mario Galaxy

Honourable mentions

Orange Box - Specifically portal and TF2
Bioshock
Crackdown
Trackmania United
Civ 4 - Beyond the Sword
Skate

Most Disappointing GOTY
Supreme Commander - No character or charm but a decent enough RTS

[Leon Retro]

Most Disappointing GOTY

Sega Rally


It doesn't feel as good as the original. As much as it tries to be a SEGA Arcade title, I didn't feel it achieved it. The movement feels floaty, and strange. Everything is mediocre, except the music, which is a nightmare.

I wish Sega would go back to their routes and make pure Japanese style experiences. Western designers have their own ideas when it comes to style and design. I don't think they should be in charge of updating classic Japanese games, it doesn't work well.

[endo]

GOTY

Skate

HONOURABLE MENTIONS

Super Mario Galaxy (very nearly first but I haven't played it as much)
Call of Duty 4
PGR4
Orange Box

[Spiral]

GotY
Halo 3

Honourable Mentions:
Okami
Portal
Virtua Fighter 5
Final Fantasy XII