ezee, i genuinely do not think it is an overreaction. The foul on the last attacker (Keane I think) was possibly covered by Rio but it was quite far from him and Keane would be definite favourite to get the shot away (although, knowing keane he would have scuffed it). It was a professional foul.
Marginal decision that time but min Vidic was not really that bothered by the crumpled heap of Alonso and lead with his elbow straight into his head. He elbowed him at full speed basically - a red card offence. I actually really like Vidic as a player, strong and usually fair which is why I was surprised to see him do that. Alonso seems to be on the receiving end of a lot of dirt over the years (Lampard and Scholes spring to mind) - maybe he is very annoying?
I am happy to retract the statement if, when I watch MOTD they show it better than the two or three times i saw it.
Having now seen MOTD coverage, cannot say my initial reading has changed. As analysed on MOTD, NV was last man for the slide on Keane. Watching the elbow again, it still looks like a straight red. I think a two yellow ban is shorter than one for violent play. Seeing as Terry got a straight red for far less,it strikes me as a little odd.
Marginal decision that time but min Vidic was not really that bothered by the crumpled heap of Alonso and lead with his elbow straight into his head. He elbowed him at full speed basically - a red card offence. I actually really like Vidic as a player, strong and usually fair which is why I was surprised to see him do that. Alonso seems to be on the receiving end of a lot of dirt over the years (Lampard and Scholes spring to mind) - maybe he is very annoying?

I am happy to retract the statement if, when I watch MOTD they show it better than the two or three times i saw it.
Having now seen MOTD coverage, cannot say my initial reading has changed. As analysed on MOTD, NV was last man for the slide on Keane. Watching the elbow again, it still looks like a straight red. I think a two yellow ban is shorter than one for violent play. Seeing as Terry got a straight red for far less,it strikes me as a little odd.
Comment