Originally posted by abigsmurf
View Post
Just felt like saying it again - while the basic plot points in D.P. are little different from your average airport novel, the way in which the story is told, the characterisation is developed, much of the acting and the way in which the story ends are genuinely amazing. Not 'so bad it's good'. Amazing.
It ranks as some of the best writing in a game I've ever seen, and in terms of emotional impact it's up there with Silent Hill 2 and Planescape: Torment.
At the same time, it's also hilarious. The diner scene is properly funny, for example, not simply 'Oh, you wacky Japanese developers!' funny because it's fantastically written and acted and there's a beautifully succinct reason York behaves the way he does. A significant portion of the script is silly, awkward and over the top, I'm not arguing that. But much of it is genuinely brilliant, and it frustrates me how many people (not specifically you, smurf, just saying) will dismiss it out of hand.
Comment